Below are the starting prices of our most popular items; from there, the price will go up according to the complexity of the design and work involved.

The total price of your order depends on several factors, including number of servings, complexity of the design, special flavor requests, the cost of the ingredients and top-quality packaging, and the time taken to answer each special request and create a unique design, preparations for your order,
and the meticulous care 
that goes into creating your edible masterpiece!

All of our custom cakes are at least 4 layers, made with the highest quality and freshest ingredients, and we never ever use pre-made mixes!

Quotes will be provided via email and not over the phone, simply to help keep track of all details and with customer service in mind!

Elements like toppers, flowers, figurines, handmade sugar details, custom painting, logos and more can affect the price of the cake; the price always reflects the amount of time it takes to put such elements together, and the high prices of these special ingredients. 


1/4 sheet cake (2 layers) feeds 45-50 starts at $250

1/2 sheet cake (2 layers) feeds 75-80 starts at $400

4" Cake feeds 6-8- starts at $85

6" Cake feeds 10-12 starts at $125

8" Cake feeds 18-20 starts at $200

Smash Cakes start at $50  

Our most popular 3-tone ombre smash cakes are $60.

(Smash Cakes are 2-to-3-layer 4” vanilla cake, naturally nut-free, filled and iced with fluffy vanilla buttercream; pick-up only)

Cupcakes and cookies are ordered by the dozen—

Regular cupcakes start at $50/dozen ,minimum 1 dozen order 

Mini cupcakes start at $30/dz, minimum 2 dozen order

*We are delighted to offer COVID-safe single-serve boxing for our full-size cupcakes for $20/dozen which includes labor and cost*

Marble-iced sugar cookies start at $48/dozen, minimum 1/2 dozen order

** A 50% non-refundable retainer is required to secure your booking. Remaining balance is required 7 days prior to delivery or collection.  

Cakes will not be completed without full payment in advance**


• Scheduled curbside pick-up encouraged •

• Delivery is available within Midtown-Uptown for an additional fee, minimum $75 order •


• Corey Michelle Cakes is located on the Upper East Side of NYC