Before You Order

Pricing and Serving Details:

We always like to be very clear with our clients on pricing of Corey Michelle Cakes products, and each custom cake is custom priced based on many different factors. All quotes will be provided via email and not over the phone, simply to help keep track of all details and with customer service in mind! 

Cakes are normally charged per serving**; custom buttercream cakes are priced $8-12 per slice for a basic but beautiful design. This is the starting point and from there the price will go up according to the complexity of the design and work involved.  

**Smaller cakes have minimum prices


Elements like sugar paste flowers, figurines, other handmade sugar details, custom painting, logos and more can affect the price of the cake. 

The price always reflects the amount of time it takes to put such elements together, and the high prices of these special ingredients.


Smash Cakes start at $45 for a 4” vanilla, naturally nut-free, cake with fluffy buttercream and sprinkles.  

Ombre Smash cakes are $55.

Cupcakes and cookies are ordered by the dozen—

cupcakes minimum 1 dozen start at $36/dz, mini cupcakes minimum 2 dozen start at $18/dz

marble sugar cookies minimum 1 dozen at $36/dozen

Flavors & Ingredients:

All of Corey Michelle Cakes' products are made from fresh high quality ingredients, and we never, ever use premade mixes. All  our confections are made-to-order custom from start to finish, and we pride ourselves on the fact that our cakes taste just as remarkable as they look.

We can accommodate most flavor requests, please include in your quote request.

** A 50% non-refundable retainer is required to secure your booking. Remaining balance is required 7 days prior to delivery or collection.  

Cakes will not be completed without full payment in advance**


• Corey Michelle Cakes is located on the Upper East Side of NYC • Scheduled curbside pick-up encouraged •

• Delivery available within Manhattan only for an additional fee •

Corey Michelle Cakes is not a nut-free, dairy-free, soy-free, sugar-free or wheat-free facility. While some products may be free of these ingredients, all products at Corey Michelle Cakes have the chance of sharing the air with sister ingredients, and anyone highly allergic should take caution when consuming our products -- at their own risk. Thank you for understanding!

©2020 by Corey Michelle Cakes Inc.

  • Instagram
  • Facebook